I went thru' the same process earlier this year... I think I my have lost sleep trying to decide "Run-flats, or not?"
After running on non-runflats for 6 months, I can say that it was one of the best upgrades I made on my XLR-V. They ride quieter, significantly smoother, and its a night/day difference in grip - additionally, I saved money over the cost of the runflats and I gain a tremendous amount of wet traction over the runflats.
Knowing what I know now, I'm glad I made the choice to abandon the runflats.
I know that without doing a pepsi-challenge of your own its hard to say which is better, but I thought I'd share my experience.
Additionally - I also initially worried about getting a flat or ruining a TPM sensor.
First - cost - at $50 a sensor, I can pay for a replacement sensor and still save money over the runflat tire cost difference - assuming I do use a can of fix-a-flat. Additionally, I've been buying salvage sensors on ebay for about $25 as spares.
2nd - I learned about plug kits and I also learn how easy it is to just plug a tire on the side of the road, which saves the TPM and some will argue is a permanent fix (some people say it will leak again, but with high performance tires that only last 15k miles anyway its most likely not a problem). Any flat caused by a nail or puncture that can be fixed with a can of fix-a-flat can be fixed with a plug kit - and the plug kit can fix larger holes than the can will fix.
So now I pack a plug kit, a 12v tire pump, flashlight, a multitool, and about 10 latex gloves in that small compartment in the trunk (it only takes of 1/2 the room). Hopefully I will never have to use it, and if all else fails there's always onstar.
But for me, I will NEVER go back to runflats except for a regular passenger car/truck...
YMMV
