Here's a thread I found on one of the Vette boards:
Tunnel plate for C5 - Page 2 - CM
Seems like it makes a bigger difference for the C5s instead of the C6s, which makes sense since the C5's stock plate is so thin.
One guy with a 2008 Vette stated: "I had one put in and wasn't that impressed with the end result. I wouldn't recommend this mod."
However, this thread is from 2007, so his car was brand new at the time. And he has a Z06, which I don't believe comes in convertible form.
I've test driven lower mile XLRs (ones with <20k), and they feel a lot tighter than mine with 70k miles. With age, most convertible start to loosen up....so I'm wondering if this is a good way to help cure that for our cars?
I previously owned a Honda S2000, and the structure seemed more rigid/stiffer than the XLR. However, I sold it at 45k miles, so not sure how they hold up beyond that.