Thanks for the replies. To be clear, I'm not trying to start a fire or complain about the car. I'm just looking for solutions to a problem.
I'm sure some of the damage may be caused by the belts, but a number of the dents are so small that they look like it would have taken something more pointed than the seatbelt tab to inflict. Keys could do some of it, no question, but the damage is pretty widespread, especially considering it is a keyless car.
I don't know whether the '09 console is equally vulnerable (or substitutable), but I would have hoped the problem would have been corrected earlier in the game. Arguably, the material may have been in some way under-spec'd.
After all, it's not as if the seating position is significantly different from a C5/C6 Corvette, and I can't say I've seen anything similar on any Corvette.
I've seen several posts where GM has covered the damage, and if anybody body has had that done under warranty I'd appreciate hearing from them.
I also wonder if, failing that, a paintless dent removal place would be able to straighten the situation out. One person did suggest using a wood trim kit, but I'm not familiar with them.