That's exactly what my initial reaction was to the XLR & CTS coupe when they were first introduced.
Over time (a long time), my opinion changed to not only accepting them, but eventually owning one (2008 XLR-V).
Designs that are different, unconventional, groundbreaking & ahead of their time can be polarizing at first & initially difficult to accept.
In time, good design will grow on you & you begin to appreciate the finer nuances & aspects of the design.
Well, this is where we will continue to differ.
I
loved the
Evoq the first time I saw it. When Cadillac revealed the
XLR, I
loved it as well and knew that at some point I would
have to have one. The design of the Evoq was changed very little to become the XLR. The first XLR I saw in person was in Crimson Pearl and I knew right away that I would end up owning one in that color.
I liked the Cadillac "Art & Science" design when I first saw it. It did not need to "grow on me". To this day, I find the XLR to be one of the most beautiful cars produced in the modern era. To me, it is very balanced and all the proportions are right. A friend of mine stated that an XLR looks like "a knife traveling down the road".
As far as the design of the car we are discussing is concerned, it looks too "cartoonish" to me, almost like the exaggerated cartoons of muscle cars that were popular in the 60's and 70's. It looks too much like a XLR that has had the greenhouse shrunk and the fenders and front-end enlarged. The proportions are all wrong to me. The front end appears to be too wide for the car.
One of the many things I like about the XLR is the sharp-edged angular design. With the exception of the wheelwells, there are hardly any circular or rounded edges on the car. It quite literally looks like origami. This car has an awkward blend of angular design and curves. As mentioned before, the wheels are too big.
I have always liked the sharp-edged crisp design on an automobile. I had a 1981 Cadillac Eldorado, which to me was one of the best looking Eldorados ever. I also had a 1981 Cutlass, which had that sharp angular look to it.
But it's all about personal opinion and perception. This design just doesn't do it for me.
I'll probably be all alone here, but it won't be the first time.